Chapter 718: The retrial is at a disadvantage
Time flies, and the date of the second trial is coming soon, Qi Zhengping is also ready, he went out of the mountain again, which attracted the attention of people from all walks of life, and everyone couldn't help but speculate that Tian Xiaonuan was sacred, and he could invite Barrister Qi out of the mountain.
Because some of the evidence cannot be used, lawyer Qi intends to start with the plaintiff who hurt Peng Hong twice, and mainly argue that Peng Hong was rational when she did these things, not crazy.
This is Qi Zhengping's worst plan, which means that he has taken a step back, when Peng Hong is intermittent psychosis, although now he also knows that this illness is fake.
Meng Jin saw that Qi Zhengping really came out to defend, although he hated him for not giving himself face, but on the surface, he showed great respect for lawyer Qi, and also won him everyone's praise in court.
As soon as the trial began, lawyer Qi first threw out an important piece of evidence to prove that Peng Hong's heart disease was fake, so as to explain that Peng Hong had a black history in making fake medical certificates, so I hope that the intermittent psychosis report she is providing now can be re-examined.
Lawyer Qi took out the physical examination report of Peng Hong's unit, their unit has a biennial employee physical examination, and Peng Hong is normal for the above heart examination, and this report, Lawyer Qi submitted five copies at one time, that is, ten years, which can prove that in the past ten years, Peng Hong's heart disease is nothing.
Lawyer Qi also invited some witnesses, one of her unit, two in the community, and the one in the unit was married to Peng Hong in the early years, and her testimony was that Peng Hong was the main force of the unit's badminton team, and she also participated in badminton competitions organized by the district trade union on behalf of the unit many times, and she did not look like a person with heart disease at all.
The two people in the community can't come up with any evidence, but after all, they have lived for so many years, and they all said that because Peng Hong's father has no medical insurance, but he has had heart disease for many years, they always see Peng Hong prescribe medicine and take it out, and greet them on weekdays, and they also heard Peng Hong personally say that he would send medicine to his father.
These two people were both people who had a holiday with Cao Xinjie when the government divided the house.
Meng Jin immediately objected, saying only that his client took the medicine, could it be that the medicine must have been prescribed by the person concerned in the hospital? Why couldn't it be that the person concerned bought it in an outside pharmacy, and it was normal to give medicine to his father, saying that this kind of testimony was not enough to prove these things.
As for the people in Peng Hong's unit, Meng Jin proposed that if the heart disease is not very serious and well controlled, it can also be exercised moderately, and Meng Jin believes that being entangled in a heart disease has nothing to do with this case.
The judge thought about it for a while and ruled that Meng Jin was right, and indeed she could not infer that her other thing must be false from making a false report on a certain matter, and this statement also lacked strong evidence to prove it, so it could only be regarded as a subjective assumption, and it also rejected Qi Zhengping's request to conduct a heart examination for Peng Hong again.
Meng Jin smiled proudly, but quickly hid the smug look in his eyes, and still made a look of respect for everyone, but he became more and more arrogant in his heart, and thought how powerful Qi Zhengping could be, but Erer, an old lawyer, since he didn't know that the evidence should be accurate and powerful, could he expect to impress the judge with a few words of witnesses.
Qi Zhengping's mood did not fluctuate, if this matter does not work, then proceed to the next one, Qi Zhengping asked for questioning of the defendant, and the judge allowed it.
"Defendant, how long did you plan to pour sulfuric acid on the plaintiff?"
"I don't know, I didn't have a plan, I don't even remember I did it. Peng Hong refused to admit it at all.
"You don't have a plan, can you ask Tian Xiaonuan to meet on the hillside of the school lake? And you also used the words in the newspaper to piece together an appointment letter, if it wasn't carefully planned, it would have been thought out a long time ago, I don't think people with the disease can have this kind of thinking. ”
"Judge, I object, the plaintiff's lawyer is misleading my client. As soon as Meng Jin heard Qi Zhengping ask about the key place, he immediately noticed that something was wrong and objected to Qi Zhengping's question again.
"The objection is invalid. The judge dismissed Meng Jin, and he thought it was necessary to confirm whether the defendant was conscious at this time.
"I ...... I don't know, it's also because a few days ago, I read a book of "Bosom Friend", because there is a story on it, about the original match to splash a little trisulfuric acid, and then one afternoon, I looked at my daughter's diary, and saw her unpleasant and even sad things at school, which made my head mess up all of a sudden, and then what I did, I just think back now, I can't remember it vaguely, I don't know that I did it too. ”
"Judge, this is the magazine, there is indeed a crime procedure on it, exactly the same as the one of the parties, I think that after the parties are not sober, they just instinctively have a mentality of revenge for the child. Meng Jin presented the magazine, and the stories in it had already been folded.
Immediately, Meng Jin invited a psychiatric expert, and the doctor said that intermittent psychosis, it is possible that the patient will carry out some harmful behaviors according to the subconscious, of course, it may also be directly stimulated, have a seizure on the spot, and there is a possibility of causing harm to others.
After that, Lawyer Qi raised it again for the second time, and Peng Hong found Tian Xiaonuan's house to make trouble, and this matter was immediately defeated by Meng Jin's evidence.
Thanks to Cao Xinjie, Peng Hong was sent to a psychiatric hospital, which is strong evidence, Peng Hong recently because of the pressure of losing her daughter, which stimulated her condition again, and there is a tendency to worsen, Peng Hong's final admission to the hospital is the most powerful proof.
Qi Zhengping's arguments several times were rejected by Meng Jin's strong evidence, he knew that he could not continue today, otherwise he would definitely lose, so he asked for an adjournment, and the trial would be held in a month, and the case would be closed without strong evidence.
Out of the courtroom, Lawyer Qi frowned, he had already told He Silang and Tian Xiaonuan, at present, I am afraid that I have to be prepared to lose, after all, the things they secretly photographed, they can't be used as evidence, if it is exposed, this lawsuit will be won, and other legal responsibilities will be pursued, Lawyer Qi thinks that it is better not to break out.
And Meng Jin's lawsuit stepped on Lawyer Qi's head and made him famous, the famous Lawyer Qi was not his opponent back then, and many people looked for Meng Jin for a while, but Meng Jin still pushed it all away very responsibly, and Peng Hong's lawsuit must be closed first.
He didn't expect that Lawyer Qi, who Tian Xiaonuan invited, didn't help her, but actually promoted himself, Meng Jin was very proud, listening to the flattery of his peers, he was a little fluttering.
Out of the courtroom, in the bathroom, Tian Xiaonuan met Peng Hong, she was very puzzled, Cao Xinjie was like this, why Peng Hong still wanted to defend him.
Looking at the indifferent Peng Hong, Tian Xiaonuan was also a little unable to see through.