Chapter 1393 - Unintelligible
Chapter 1393 - Unintelligible
The little emperor's words surprised everyone present, Wang Yinglin and Xie Fang are self-explanatory, and they are recognized as Confucian masters at the moment. Chen Shishi and Ma Duanlin are both from official families, and their father and brother are also famous Confucians who are familiar with the scriptures and history. Even Ni Liang, a rough man, followed the little emperor as a companion, and worshiped Ying Jie Yan as a teacher, not proficient, but also coarse and knowledgeable.
However, each person's performance is different, the person Ni Liang cares about is whether he can really fly into the sky, and what is the other side of the ocean like; Chen Shishi and Ma Duanlin, two young people, were more interested in the vast universe and the rising and setting of the sun in the east and in the west that His Majesty said, and pestered His Majesty to ask endlessly. Wang Yinglin and Xie Fangde fell into deep thought, considering the deep meaning of His Majesty's words.
After thinking about it carefully, there were two 'conflicts' between Zhu Xi and Lu Jiuyuan, one was the meeting of Goose Lake and the other was the meeting of White Deer. Zhu and Lu engaged in a heated debate, making the contradictions between them public.
The meeting of Goose Lake took place in the spring of the second year of Chunxi. When Lu Zuqian visited Zhu Xi to Wuyi, the two read Zhou, Zhang, and Ercheng books together, and edited "Recent Reflections". Later, Zhu Xi sent Lu Zuqian to the Ehu Temple in Xinzhou, where Lu Suzhi Zhu and Lu had differences in their views on science and wanted to reconcile and unify them, so they asked Lu Jiuling and Lu Jiuyuan to come to Ehu for a meeting to discuss academic issues. Lu Zishou, Lu Zijing, Liu Zicheng and friends from Jiangsu and Zhejiang all came to the meeting, which was later called the "Goose Lake Meeting".
At the Goose Lake meeting, Erlu advocated "easy simplicity", which was based on the premise of confirming the innate mind. It shows that the "heart" ontology is first established and the heart is the root of all moral values, and advocates the extension of reading and learning from the "clear heart", and believes that the sages of the ages only passed on from the heart to the heart, and do not need to pass on the words. Zhu Xi advocated the method of learning and learning, first exposing and then returning to the appointment.
Therefore, Lu Jiuyuan wanted to argue with Zhu Xi even more, thinking that "what books can be read before Yao Shun". This shows that he believes that Zhu Xi's "fragmentation" lies not only in the fact that the method is not simple, but also in the failure to find the true source of moral values. The two sides have their own opinions, Lu Jiuling and Lu Jiuyuan also endowed poems and Mingzhi, ridiculing Zhu Xi's gradual cultivation of kung fu as "fragmented", and it is inevitable to look at it generally. This caused Zhu Xi's dissatisfaction, and the two sides debated for three days, but their views were never unified.
After the meeting at Goose Lake, another important meeting between Zhu Lu and Zhu Lu was the meeting of Nankang. In the eighth year of Chunxi, Zhu Xi knew the Nankang army, and in February, Lu Jiuyuan visited Zhu Xi in Nankang, and Zhu Xi invited Lu Jiuyuan to give a lecture at Bailudong Academy. The main points of contention between the two are 'the distinction between righteousness and benefit', 'the dispute between Wuji and Taiji', and 'the way of yin and yang'.
Lu Jiuyuan talked about the chapter of "The Analects of the Analects" "The gentleman is said to be righteous, and the villain is said to be profitable", and he believes that the core problem of Confucianism in judging the gentleman and the villain by righteousness and profit is to distinguish the will. People's knowledge comes from the habits of daily life, and the results of the habits are determined by your aspirations. Those who are determined to "benefit" will be driven by "profit"; Those who aspire to "righteousness" take "righteousness" as the code of conduct.
Therefore, the key to learning lies in determination. He linked to the system of selecting talents in the imperial examination at that time, and said: The imperial examination has been taking scholars for a long time, and the famous Confucian and great princes have all come out of this. Those who are now scholars are not exempt from this. However, the gains and losses of the field house, regardless of its skills and the likes and dislikes of the division, are not so distinguishable as gentlemen and villains. And in this world, so that they are submerged in this place and cannot extricate themselves, then those who are engaged all day long, although they are called the book of the sages, but the place where they want to be, there are those who go against the sages.
Lu Jiuyuan also used the "distinction of righteousness and benefit" to talk about the difference between Confucianism and interpretation, and believed that the difference between Confucianism and Buddhism does not lie in the nothingness and reality of the ontology, but in the use of this ontology to prove the idea of being born in the world or being born. Confucianism talks about life, humanity, and personnel, all for the sake of "going through the world"; Buddhism talks about life and death and reincarnation, just to escape the suffering and troubles of life. Therefore, even if the moral cultivation of Confucianism reaches the state of "silent, odorless, squareless, and bodyless", it will never be confused with the nihilistic ontology of Buddhism.
The listeners were very moved, and even those who wept, Zhu Xi immediately left his seat and said to everyone: "Xi should stay with all living beings and not forget Mr. Lu's teachings." And repeatedly said, "Xi has never said this here, what is the shame." He also asked Lu Jiuyuan to write a handout and engrave it on stone as a commemoration.
About Wuji and Tai Chi. The different interpretations of "Tai Chi" between the two sides actually show the view of "Li", that is, the different angles of definition. Zhu Xixun's "extreme" is the "extreme", Taiji is the sum of "reason", the ultimate extreme of all things in heaven and earth; The meaning of the saint is to be the ultimate in its end, nameless, so it is called Tai Chi. "The principle of nature", "not belonging to existence, not falling cube", no name can be named, so it is also called "Wuji"; If you don't talk about Tai Chi, then Tai Chi will be reduced to emptiness, and it cannot be the root of Wanhua.
Lu Jiuyuan trained the "extreme" as "middle", thinking that "Taiji" is "practical reason". He thinks that "reason" is about the principle of daily life, and what the sage focuses on is how to practice morality, "words are their deeds, things are their words, the so-called words and deeds, and deeds are considered words." Rather than going around in circles on the name, any carving of language and words is not conducive to the understanding of "reason". He also pointed out: "The word 'Wuji' comes from the "Lao Tzu Zhi Qi Xiong Zhang", which is the purpose of Lao's learning from beginning to end, and he uses the different names of "Wuji" and "Taiji" to show that "reason" and "matter" have a metaphysical and metaphysical difference.
Lu Jiuyuan thought that yin and yang were metaphysical ways, which summarized all opposing things and phenomena in the universe. "Yi" is the way, one yin and one yang, successively, always, moving, obscure, up and down, advancing and retreating, coming and going, and closing...... Why not one yin and one yang? The so-called reason, regardless of heaven and man, reason and desire, is the principle of the unity of the three poles, and man is the master of reason in this reason, so there is a saying that "yin and yang are metaphysical".
Zhu Xi regards yin and yang as the "metaphysical" instrument, and regards it as the material that constitutes all things in the universe. Therefore, it is the reason of the instrument, and the Tao is also. The so-called always, obscure, and strange couplings are all instruments made by yin and yang, and they are the only ones that are the principles of instruments...... It's the Domp......
"Where does the fifth brother think the dispute between Zhu Xue and Lu Xue lies?" After thinking for a long time, Wang Yinglin interrupted the conversation between the little emperor and Nian Qiangren and asked.
"I think that the so-called 'respect for virtue' of Lu Xue and the 'Taoism' of Zhu Xue, the argument between them is just that the entry method of learning Confucianism is different. It's like tea on this case. It's the same pot of tea, but I like to drink herbal tea, while Mr. Wang likes to drink hot tea. Can you say that drinking hot tea is right and drinking herbal tea is wrong? Zhao Yu pointed to the two cups of tea on the desk.
"Would you like to ask the fifth brother to explain in detail?" The little emperor actually said that the argument between the two factions was so simple, which made Wang Yinglin extremely surprised, and then said.
"Hmm......" Zhao Yu pondered for a moment and organized his words, "Zhu Xue takes reading as the general, and intends to determine the ultimate essence of all things after finding them. He first focused on nature, intending to deduce the ontology of 'so-so' from the laws of nature, and deduced this to 'what is natural', and regarded the 'metaphysical' principle of course as the root of life activities and moral consciousness. In fact, it is to take things as the object of cognition, make intellectual generalizations, and generalize them into reason. Therefore, he attaches great importance to the expression and teaching of language, and the generalization and abstraction of logic. In terms of methodology, it advocates reading and considering words, and requires people to take reading as the main method of exhaustion. ”
Lu Xue takes respect for virtue as the key, thinking that this is the key to learning Confucianism, and puts the transformation of the distinction between righteousness and benefit in the first place. He believes that knowing more about the truth cannot change people's thinking, because on the back of knowledge, there is something that determines the direction of people's knowledge, which is the aspiration, that is, the foundation of people and the motivation to do things. Its study is based on the moral subject, and what it pursues is actually a kind of rationality. He also takes intuition as the ontology, believing that although this ontology is above human knowledge, it is not separated from human knowledge. Therefore, he emphasized the respect for virtue, and enriched the ontology with the means of seeking knowledge as a supplement to virtue. ”
"So I think that the methods of the two masters can't be completely separated, their original intentions are to plant the same gang and support the famous religion together, and although Zhu Lu emphasizes one side in it, he also takes into account the other side, so their controversy cannot constitute a fundamental difference. Even if it is different, it is just a matter of seeing the benevolent and the wise, just like tea that is too cold will freeze your teeth, and if it is too hot, it will burn your mouth. ”
"Hehe, although the fifth brother's words are brief, they also tell the key to the argument between the two!" Xie Fangde was also amused by the little emperor's slightly witty statement, and asked with a smile, "After Zhu Xue's advocacy of knowledge first, does the fifth brother think it is the correct solution?" ”
Zhao Yu understood that Zhu Xi's concept of knowledge and action refers to the personal moral cultivation and practice of Confucianism. Since moral practice requires the guidance of feudal ethics, "knowledge comes first". And because feudal ethics cannot just be empty talk, "behavior is important". If Zhao Yu is allowed to look at it from the perspective of cognition, "knowing first and then later" reverses the relationship between primary and secondary. As a science student, he certainly knows the truth that 'theory comes from practice, and theory guides practice'. This is a truth that modern people agree on, but not now, and arguing with it will fall into a 'chicken or egg' debate.
"It's not that complicated!" Zhao Yu said in a deep voice, "In fact, this is like a baby learning to walk, whether to let him step first or his right leg first, in fact, it doesn't matter which leg he steps first." But I have to make it clear, I think the most important thing is to remember where to fall, and the next time I see the ditch, I will walk around! ”
"Haha...... The fifth brother is right, if a person trips over a pit twice, then he is a fool! Ni Liang laughed when he heard this.
"What the fifth brother said is good, practice can produce true knowledge!" Wang Yinglin nodded with a straight face.
"Hehe, this is just some of my feelings since I was a child, I suffered Chen Yizhong's first secret loss at that time, and I didn't fight back categorically. And the second time I met him, he wanted my life, so I knew that I must not give him another chance, otherwise my life would be ruined! Zhao Hao laughed dryly and said......
Book Keju Reading Website: