Chapter 1366: How to Choose
After a conversation, Zhao Yu has basically understood the evolution of the political system in history through Wang Yinglin's explanation and his own knowledge, and also understands that the change of the system is actually the change in the relationship between the royal family and the imperial court. If the royal family and the imperial court are separated, how will the powers of the two sides be divided?
This can be glimpsed from the change of the name of the prime minister, the name of the official position in different eras is different, but in fact it has the same function. When the power of the prime minister was so great that the emperor felt that his authority was threatened, he set up new secretarial offices with lower status cronies, either by new names or by the names of existing positions. Then this secretarial body replaced the original prime minister's office as the real power body, and then became the legitimate prime minister's body.
And this is the so-called dereliction of duty of the prime minister. Because of the power of the prime minister, he should have led the government and ruled the whole country, but the emperor Lao'er felt insecure and took away this power, and put their secretaries like Zhongshu Menxia Shangshu to act as the prime minister of the government, and most of them were in the Wei, Jin, Southern and Northern Dynasties era after the Eastern Han Dynasty.
The Han Dynasty's first secrets were the Shangshu and then the Zhongshu, which came from the secretarial office of Cao Cao's prime minister's office. After Cao Pi usurped the throne, it became Zhongshu Province, and then Menxia Province, this institution was very important in the Western Jin Dynasty and the Northern Dynasties, there were two levels of Shizhong and Huangsan, Huangsan is the combined name of Huangmen Shilang and Sanqi Changshi, at this time the Southern Dynasty corresponds to Zhongshu Tongshi Sheren.
But when the people in charge were all high and powerful, and the emperor felt that he could not be trusted, he would set up a new secretarial body, and history entered a new cycle. Once they don't do anything serious, the emperor can't trust them, and then there is the Privy Council of the Tang Dynasty and the Military Aircraft Department of the Manchu Dynasty. The difference is that the post-Tang Dynasty is no longer the old Han Dynasty, the old system, but with a new set.
The government power of the Tang Dynasty has been divided between the government and the royal family, as far as the government is concerned, it has changed greatly, the prime minister of the Han Dynasty is to adopt the leadership system, the most important thing in the government is the power of the minister, if the power changes, all the system must change with it. The prime minister of the Tang Dynasty adopted the committee system, that is, the power of the former prime minister was formally assigned to the three provinces. In other words, to return some of the former royal powers to the government.
The three-province six-ministry system is highly respected and praised for its many advantages. For example, it is conducive to brainstorming and improving administrative efficiency; It is conducive to strengthening the rights of the monarch and maintaining feudal rule; It is conducive to improving the cultural quality of officials and promoting the development of culture. Zhao Hao also feels the same way:
From the perspective of the inheritance of the system. The system of three provinces and six ministries in the Sui and Tang dynasties, the system of three provinces and six ministries is the development of the system of three princes and nine ministers since the Qin and Han dynasties. The three provinces of Zhongshu, Menxia and Shangshu were co-ordinated, which dispersed the power of the prime minister, strengthened the imperial power, and perfected the absolutist centralized system; Judging by the transformation of functions. The establishment of the three provinces and the six ministries were all dealing with government affairs, and there were special agencies and personnel to deal with the internal affairs of the palace, and its establishment indicated the complete separation of royal affairs from state affairs, and was a great progress in the political system; From the point of view of the checks and balances of power, the balance between imperial power and relative power has been achieved to a certain extent.
In accordance with the functions of the three provinces and six ministries, the decision of the Chinese book, the review and approval of the subordinates or the refutation, and the implementation of the book, and then the distribution of the six departments for implementation. According to the modern political science system, Zhongshu and his subordinates actually play the role of the legislature and the decision-making department of the highest administrative organ; Shangshu and its six ministries are actually the non-decision-making executive organs of the Government Affairs Yuan.
As for what department the six departments correspond to now, because the classification structure of the ancient bureaucratic system is complex and completely different from that of modern times, it is difficult to accurately correspond one by one.
The Ministry of Officials, which is equivalent to the current Department of Organizational Cadres, includes the four divisions of literature selection, merit examination, seal inspection, and audit honor; The Ministry of Household is equivalent to the current complex of the Ministry of Finance, the Central Bank, the State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission, the Ministry of Land and Resources, and the Ministry of Civil Affairs. The Ministry of Rites is equivalent to the current Propaganda Department, Ministry of Education, Ministry of Culture, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, etc.; the Ministry of War, which is equivalent to the current Ministry of Defense and the four general departments; The Criminal Department is related to the current judicial organs such as the Public Procuratorate and the Law; The Ministry of Industry is related to the current Ministry of Construction, the Ministry of Water Resources and the Bureau of Agricultural Reclamation.
What are the responsibilities of the six ministries, although the books of each ministry are of the same grade, but the degree of importance is still in order. Generally, the six parts are sorted according to rich, noble, mighty, martial, poor, and low.
Rich refers to the household, and the household is in charge of money and grain, so the household symbolizes wealth; You refer to the Ministry of Officials, and the Ministry of Officials is in charge of officials of all sizes in and outside Beijing, so the Ministry of Officials occupies a noble word; Prestige refers to the criminal department, and the criminal department must shout majesty when trying the case, so the criminal department is indeed majestic; Wu refers to the military department, which is in charge of warfare, swords, guns, and grain, which is also worthy of the name; Poverty refers to the Ministry of Rites, its discipline, Qingshui Yamen, poverty is normal; And cheap refers to the Ministry of Industry, because the people they deal with are craftsmen, they are engaged in cheap business, so the Ministry of Industry has a cheap word.
In the administrative process of the three-province six-ministry system, the Zhongshu Province was responsible for drafting the edict, the Menxia Province was responsible for sealing and refuting the edict, and the Shangshu Province was responsible for implementing the edict. And the edicts drafted by Zhongshu Province represent the emperor's will, and isn't the review and refutation of these edicts by Menxia Province reviewing and refuting the emperor's will? Does this mean that imperial power will actually be limited by the three-province system?
To be exact, Zhao Yu believes that there is, although the emperor system or the title of emperor has determined that the imperial power is supreme, and no one can limit or restrict the imperial power. But because the emperor needs to exercise power through certain personnel and institutions, in accordance with certain procedures and methods. The system of three provinces and six ministries systematically provided the possibility for his subordinates to restrain the emperor's behavior, so that he would not abuse the imperial power.
Zhao Yu was deeply affected by his refutation, and the will he issued needed to be drafted in the Chinese book, and his subordinates were responsible for review. If the province feels that there is a problem with the edict, it will alter the edict and then send it back, and this behavior has a special name, called Tugui. And Menxia Province not only examines the emperor's edicts, but also the concerts played to the emperor by various localities and departments must first be reviewed by Menxia Province.
If the ministry thinks it is reasonable, it will sign the review opinion, submit it to the Zhongshu province for discussion and submit it to the emperor's imperial review, and if the ministry thinks it is unreasonable, it will sign the objection opinion and send it back. It can be seen that both Zhongshu Province and Menxia Province intervened in the emperor's words and deeds to a certain extent, trying to make the emperor's actions within the institutional framework, so that the emperor could not exercise dictatorship.
At first, Zhao Yu felt that his rights were restricted, and later, in the name of improving administrative efficiency, he put the Zhongshu Gate into a nominal unit. For major matters, the left and right ministers, the Governor of the Council, and the Privy Council Chairmen and Vice-Ministers will organize the court discussions, or six additional books will be added to the same court. Once it was passed, he stamped the decision and issued it directly to the six ministries or armies for execution.
As long as Zhao Hao's 'private decree' is not related to state affairs, it can be sent to six ministries or localities for implementation as long as it is signed by the left and right ministers or the governors on duty. Later, the establishment of the Military Aircraft Department was also for the purpose of squeezing the power of the minister, and later a series of drafts of edicts and examination of the recitals were also handed over to the Imperial Front Office, so that some people called the head of the Imperial Front Office 'the internal minister', and there was a tendency to replace the foreign court.
Therefore, although Zhao Yu established the Imperial Front Office at the beginning, he only wanted to reduce his work pressure, assist him in sorting out documents, collecting information and keeping important documents, and docking the work of central and local departments, and set up a secretariat. But in fact, the current Imperial Front Office already has some functions of Zhongshu Province and Menxia Province, and participates in the early decision-making of major events, which affects the operation procedures and events of the imperial court to a certain extent.
Of course, Zhao Yu knew that it was barely reasonable to do this in wartime and deal with emergencies as a temporary institution, and his purpose was also to be influenced by his own thoughts and train as a reserve cadre by working in the Imperial Front Office. However, as the emperor's staff, these people are far from each other in terms of qualifications and administrative experience, and they cannot assume the role of counselors and military aircraft.
At present, the situation is getting better, the territory has stabilized along the Huai River, the area has expanded more than 100 times compared with the original area in Qiongzhou, and the population has reached about 40 million. Zhao Hao thought that the current imperial court institutions had not been able to keep pace with the times, not only was it difficult for him to deal with complicated affairs in a timely manner, but the imperial court was also overwhelmed.
Therefore, it is urgent to adjust the institutions of the imperial court, clarify the operating procedures and improve the deliberative and decision-making functions, so Zhao Yu thought about gradually improving the relevant institutions. However, he still only envisioned how to determine the functions of the additional departments, and did not have a detailed plan. So I mentioned this matter to Wang Yinglin today, hoping to have an eyebrow before returning to Beijing.
At present, judging from the merits of the three-province six-ministry system, it is indeed a very good system. Is it true that if there are many advantages, it will be promoted in the long run? Zhao's answer is no. After the establishment of the system under the Zhongshu Gate, the institutions of the three provinces still existed, and the division of labor in the entry and exit orders of the three provinces became stricter and more perfect in form. However, the three provinces were separated from the prime minister, and the Zhongshu became the prime minister's office, independent of the three provincial institutions.
Under this system, the Zhongshu Sect directly commanded the envoys, counties, and armies to carry out government decrees, and the Zai's intervention in administrative affairs became stronger and stronger, and even directly descended to the affairs that were handled by the six departments of Shangshu in the past. The prime minister's connection with the monarch is more that of a political official who "participates in the affairs of the general affairs" rather than a consultant who "sits and talks".
Now that he chooses to restore the three-province system, whether to completely copy the version of the previous dynasty, or to learn from the experience of his predecessors and selectively retain it, Zhao Yu is still hesitating. Because it is not only a question of increasing the number of public officials and expenses, but also a question of how to protect one's own rights and interests. Once too much power is delegated, won't your years of hard work be wasted, and you will be hollowed out again, and if you don't get it right, you will become a mascot and be offered to others......