Chapter 1439: What Can You Do
Zhao Yu was shocked and became more and more fascinated, and even Wang De couldn't let him put it down after urging him to rest several times, and he only ate a few bites of dinner in a daze, and then immersed himself in it again, until late at night, he rubbed his eyes and put down the book, and sighed: "What can I do?" ”
After reading the book for a day, it is not that Zhao Yu has become a legal expert, but he has a basic understanding of the judicial system of the Great Song Dynasty, and it is a matter for judicial personnel to memorize the law, he does not need to be proficient at all, he only needs to understand the legislative principles, the judicial system, the trial procedures and the supervision system.
Zhao Yu found that in fact, the Song Dynasty had established or had established a team of professional and full-time judicial officials. At the state level, there are generally three courts: the Dangzhi Division, the State Court, and the Administrator's Court. In some large states, the state courts and the courts of the administrators are divided into left and right courts, that is, there are five courts. Of course, some small states have merged the state court with the judicial court, leaving only one court.
Each court has a number of judges, called "Records to join the army", "Records to join the army", "Managers to join the army", and "Judicial officers to join the army". The magistrates and judges in charge of the division are also in charge of justice. Clerks who join the army, managers who join the army, and judicial officers who join the army are all full-time judges, and they are not allowed to accept other assignments except for judicial trials, even if they are sent from the imperial court, they can also refuse, that is, "even if they are selected by the decree of the court, they must not be bad", so as to ensure professionalism.
To Zhao's surprise, the Song Dynasty magistrates were very professional, and they had to pass a judicial examination before they could be appointed. This judicial examination, called "trial judge" by the Song people, was presided over by the Dali Temple and the Criminal Department, and the two departments supervised each other to prevent cheating, and accepted the supervision of the Imperial Historical Observatory. The "trial judges" are held once or twice a year, and the examination is also very detailed: six examinations at a time, five of which are for case judgment and one for jurisprudence.
The judgment of the case must state a convincing legal basis, the legal provisions to be cited, and if the facts of the case are found to be doubtful, they must also be marked on the examination paper. The examiner marks the papers one by one. To be considered passable, you must have a Distinction score and no errors in the judgment of a felony case. Zhao Hao must admit that this judicial examination system is already very strict and detailed even compared with modern times.
In terms of case-handling procedures, the power of investigation and interrogation in the Song Dynasty was separated, and the Song Dynasty legislation stipulated: "All the provinces inspect and arrest the thieves, and all the thieves shall not be tortured and interrogated first, and they shall be sent to the state capital to which they belong." "It's no different from modern times.
Song's arrest and criminal investigation agencies were the inspection department subordinate to the prefecture and road yamen, and the county lieutenant department subordinate to the county yamen, collectively known as the "patrol lieutenant", which is equivalent to today's police department, whose duties are to arrest and pursue criminal suspects, collect criminal evidence, and preside over judicial examinations. Therefore, according to the judicial system of the Song Dynasty, the investigation department could not participate in the investigation, let alone convict the suspect.
After the case enters the state court proceedings, a judge first examines the facts, which is called an "inquest". Based on witness testimony, exhibits, forensic examinations, and the suspect's confession, the investigator will interrogate the facts of the crime clearly and be able to eliminate reasonable doubt. As for what law the offender has violated and what punishment he should be sentenced according to the law, he does not care. After the defendant drew the charge, there was nothing to do with the investigator. But if the interrogation goes wrong, he is responsible.
After this procedure, we will enter the second procedure. Another judge, who does not need to avoid suspicion, reviews the case with the defendant and asks whether the defendant's confession is true and whether there are any grievances. This process is called "questioning". If the defendant complains of grievance, the previous trial procedure is reversed, and the trial must be retried in a different courtroom. This is called "disparate investigation". If the defendant does not complain, then proceed to the next procedure.
The case file is transferred to another independent judge, who will check the file for any doubts and, if any doubts are found, return it for retrial; If there is no suspicion, he will find out the legal provisions that the suspect has violated based on the facts of the crime recorded in the file, which is called "prosecuting the law". The investigation and prosecution cannot be the same judge, which is the unique system of "sub-divisions" in the Song Dynasty, which can form checks and balances of power and prevent abuse of power.
After the prosecution, the case is referred to a Sentencing Committee. The adjudication committee is responsible for drafting the judgment and submitting it to all the judges of the committee for discussion. If there is no objection to the verdict, it will be signed collectively, and if a wrongful conviction is found in the future, all the judges who signed it will be held accountable. This is called "sitting in the same office". Judges who disagree with the verdict may refuse to sign it, or attach their own dissenting opinions, which is called a "writs," and if it is later proved that the judgment was indeed wrong, the judge in the "writs" can be exempted from accountability.
The verdict must be signed by all the judges before proceeding to the next procedure: sending it to the chief judge of the court (i.e., the prefect or the prefecture) for a formal verdict. After the Chief Justice has decided the verdict, he also needs to read the verdict to the defendant and ask whether he will accept the verdict. At this time, if the defendant claims that he is not satisfied with the verdict and has a grievance to be avenged, then the procedure of "reversing the difference and making a separate investigation" will be automatically initiated - the original trial judge will recuse himself, and the higher court will organize a new court review and go through all the previous procedures again. In principle, the defendant in a criminal case has three opportunities to "turn over the differences and make other investigations".
If the defendant submits to the law after hearing the verdict, then the entire case will be concluded and submitted to the circuit courts (criminal prosecution divisions) dispatched by the central government in various places for review. If the circuit court finds any suspicions, the case will be reviewed. If no suspicion is found, the judgment can be enforced. However, if it is a death sentence and the facts of the case are doubtful, it must be reported to the Central Justice Department for review.
The modern judicial system pays attention to recusal, and the judiciary of the Song Dynasty also paid special attention to the recusal of relatives, and a very strict and thorough recusal system was set up in all aspects of judicial trial. If the court accepts a lawsuit, the first thing it needs to do before the trial is to approve the recusal judge. All those who have relatives, teachers and students, superiors and subordinates, or grudges with the plaintiff or defendant in the lawsuit, or have had a recommendation relationship, must self-declare their recusal.
What if a judge who recuses himself from responsibility does not declare? Accusations and accusations are allowed. Needless to say, this is naturally to prevent judges' judgments from being influenced by personal relationships and private feelings, and from faking public affairs and communiquating personal vendettas. In fact, it can also avoid the occurrence of human tragedies such as relatives and nephews, if Bao Zheng's nephew is brought to court for corruption and perversion of the law, then Bao Zheng must first recuse himself, and it is absolutely impossible to try the case in person.
Not only do judges who have a relationship with the litigant need to recuse themselves, but in the course of the trial of a case, the three judges who are responsible for inferencing, interrogating, and prosecuting the law must also have a relationship of kinship, otherwise they must also recuse themselves. Moreover, the law also strictly prohibits the investigators, interrogators, and prosecutors from meeting and discussing the facts of the case before the case is concluded, otherwise "each will have 80 rods."
If it is a case under review, the reviewing judge also needs to recuse himself if he has a relationship with the original trial judge; The punishment for judges who conceal their recusal obligations is very severe. Even between superior and subordinate judges must be recused – that is, judges who are related to each other cannot become superiors and subordinates. It can be said that such a system of judicial recusal has become extremely strict.
After the fourth watch, Zhao Yu covered the paper and sighed that the criminal justice procedures in the Song Dynasty were so complicated and rigorous that they could be called the crown of all dynasties, and even today, they would feel too "cumbersome". Compared with the modern system of separation of judicial powers of investigation, trial and supervision, there is only a lack of procuratorial organs, but it does not mean that there are none, but this power is replaced by a superior judge.
Zhao Yu pondered the old bag in modern film and television dramas, if it was really placed in the Song Dynasty, he would definitely not survive three episodes, he is obviously an example of taking the lead in destroying the judicial system, and what he shows is not the original appearance.
Gongsun Ce in "Three Heroes and Five Righteousness" is actually probably created by Qing Dynasty artists according to the image of the famous master at that time, there was no Gongsun Ce in the Northern Song Dynasty, and there was no so-called "master" in the state capital of the Song Dynasty. Shiye is a product of the development of the administrative shogunate system to the Ming and Qing dynasties, also known as "shogunate". The Song Dynasty was the only dynasty in history that did not have an administrative shogunate (the military and political shogunate was still preserved).
In order to infinitely elevate the tall and comprehensive image of Bao Gong's law enforcement, later generations also created a righteous and unsympathetic Bao Gong in the Peking Opera "Chisang Town" and "Bao Mian" This story is played: Bao Gong's nephew Bao Mian, for Xiaoshan County, was reported for corruption and perversion of the law, and Bao Zheng, who was ordered to go out on patrol, tried the case in person, and after finding out the truth, he ordered his nephew to be killed.
If Bao Zheng had been a judge with terrifying powers, who had the four powers of investigation, accusation, trial, and execution, and who had decided a case like the performance of "Bao Gongju," there was no doubt that it would be a serious violation of judicial procedures, and he would have been impeached and removed from office by a Taiwan official long ago. Even if he did have a nephew who committed a crime, it would not be Bao Zheng's turn to kill his relatives in righteousness.
What Zhao Hao sighed was not as tall and bright as Bao Zhengru joked, but it was a pity that the highly developed judicial system created by the Song people and the historical direction of judicial specialization were not inherited by later dynasties. The judicial system of the Yuan, Ming and Qing dynasties regressed to a very simple and rough state, and they abolished the Dali Temple, the law school, the criminal law examination, and the system of bowing and dividing the division and reversing the different investigations. In the Ming Dynasty, there was only one assistant magistrate at the prefectural level, while in the Qing Dynasty, there was no magistrate, and the administration of justice in the prefecture and county was completely handled by the chief executive.
Therefore, Zhao Hao speculated that the "Bao Gong Opera" that appeared in batches after the death of the Song Dynasty actually had nothing to do with the judicial system of the Song Dynasty, and had actually obscured the developed judicial civilization of the Song Dynasty. At most, it can only reflect part of the judicial concepts and practices of the Yuan, Ming and Qing dynasties, and it is not that the literati used the "Bao Gong Opera" to criticize the traditional judicial model, but because they were completely unaware of the elaborate judicial process design of the Song Dynasty, and could only fabricate the process of Bao Gong's trial with their self-righteous imagination.
Zhao Hao felt embarrassed that he still had to work hard to create an axe, wanting to be the vanguard of the current judicial system reform and create a new era. But fortunately, it was only a preliminary discussion stage, and there was no big joke, so what he is mainly doing now is to restore and inherit, and to train a qualified judicial team, and to improve the system......