Chapter 1460: Guilty and Not Guilty
The residence of the Provincial Lord.
Outside Han Zhaozhi's room, Shen Leng knocked on the door, Han Zhaozhi's room was still lit with lights, although it was late at night, obviously he couldn't sleep, a key criminal who had been hunted for so long died outside the stone city wall, Han Zhaozhi didn't know how to write this recital.
Hearing the knock on the door, Han Zhaozhi knew that it was Shen Leng coming.
"The door isn't plugged in."
He didn't raise his head to say a word, his eyes were still on the desk, he had been writing this recital for a full hour, but he hadn't written fifty words until now.
Shen Leng came in with two jugs of wine, put a jug of wine in front of Han Zhaozhi, and then sat down on the table, Han Zhaozhi glanced at him: "The chairs and stools in this room are all fake?" ”
Shen Leng said: "The table is wide and comfortable to sit on." ”
Han Zhaozhi asked, "Can't sleep?" ”
Shen Leng: "You? ”
Han Zhaozhi: "I'm thinking about how to participate in your book, saying that you killed Yuwen Xiaoce in a fit of anger because of venting your personal anger, resulting in no way to carry out the investigation later, such a big pot, I don't want to carry it myself, Tingweifu can't carry it, you can only carry it." ”
Shen Leng: "Well done." ”
Han Zhaozhi snorted and laughed: "Are you still thinking about that man in black?" ”
Shen Leng: "You can help me review." ”
Han Zhaozhi snorted: "It's okay." ”
Shen Leng said: "If you were the man in black, how did you avoid so many people." ”
Han Zhaozhi put down the pen in his hand and leaned back, pondering for a moment before saying, "I've actually been thinking about this all along...... After checking the box soldiers, it was determined that there were no more than one and no one was no less, and the black clothes were not found inside and outside the city wall, and you were not lying, so the only reasonable explanation is that there was a box soldier on the city wall who was the killer. ”
Shen Leng said: "It is unlikely that a master will pretend to be a box soldier in advance, this is a loophole, so it can only be that one of the box soldiers is a killer, his clothes are specially made, and he is black, it was too chaotic at the time, I didn't think of this layer at all, and now this dress should have been destroyed." ”
Han Zhaozhi: "There are still loopholes, unless all the box soldiers are in a group, otherwise the process of undressing and turning over his clothes on the city wall will definitely be seen, and now these box soldiers are still being supervised, burning clothes?" How is it possible, my people keep an eye on them. ”
Shen Leng said: "Then what if the soldiers are all in a group?" ”
"It doesn't make sense."
Han Zhaozhi said: "If all the box soldiers are in a group, and they happen to be on duty today, what is the probability of this?" Unless there is someone who knows that Yuwen Xiaoce will come today and calculates that he is going to escape from the city wall, so it is his people who arrange to be on duty on the city wall today, and there is also a peerless master who is willing to remain incognito among the soldiers for several years. ”
He glanced at Shen Leng: "I have asked people to carefully check, the shortest of the box soldiers on duty on the city wall today has been in the box soldier camp for four and a half years. ”
Shen Leng sighed: "So no one can count it four or five years ago to today." ”
"Of course no one can."
Han Zhaozhi said: "I know what you want to say, Xue Huayi is a Daocheng, and the box soldiers in Shicheng are all under his control, and the only person who has a way to make all the box soldiers lie is right?" But in fact, after my investigation, I found that it was the third day that Xue Huayi arrived in Shicheng, and he had not officially performed his duties, and he had not yet entered the camp of the Xiangbing, and the only official he had contacted many times after arriving in Shicheng was Cen Zheng, the master of the Daofu. ”
Shen Leng let out a long breath, but the squeezing in his chest was depressed but he couldn't spit it out.
"Do you think Yuwen Xiaoce's death is too simple?"
Han Zhaozhi asked.
Shen Leng nodded: "That kind of person should have 10,000 of the most cruel ways to die, he died too fast, and he didn't even have pain." ”
Han Zhaozhi said: "I remember that it was thirty years ago......"
He took a sip of wine and recalled, sorted out his words and continued: "Not long after we arrived at the Tingwei Mansion, I was nine years old and ...... At that time, it was also a big case, all the speculation was unreasonable, and we were in a bigger predicament than now, that is, at that time, the two sentences of the nine-year-old made me remember it forever and will never forget it. ”
He glanced at Shen Leng: "The nine-year-old said that when all possibilities are impossible, and all reasonableness is unreasonable, then there are only two choices, the option that seems to be the most unreasonable or the option that seems to be the most reasonable among all the unreasonable." ”
Shen Leng asked, "Why?" ”
Han Zhaozhi said: "Extreme options, all crimes are extreme behaviors, so when you have no clue, you can only choose at the extreme, either this or that." ”
He continued: "The second sentence of the nine-year-old is...... All are guilty. ”
Shen Leng frowned slightly: "Everyone is guilty? ”
Han Zhaozhi said: "When I was nine years old, I drank a lot of wine, and he said that what he said was drunk, but these words were all good words for the Tingwei Mansion to handle cases in the future...... He said, why did the Tingwei Mansion encounter such a difficult situation when investigating the case? Because all inferences and investigations are actually innocent investigations in the final analysis, what we think is impossible, to put it bluntly, that is, we think that he cannot commit a crime, so we infer innocence. ”
"The nine-year-old said that the inference of innocence is not what the Tingweifu should do, it is the lawyer's business, and what the Tingweifu wants to do is the inference of guilt, and in the eyes of the people in the Tingweifu, everyone is guilty."
He glanced at Shen Leng: "Today's case is all unreasonable, so choose two extremes among all the unreasonable." ”
Shen Leng pointed at himself: "I'm an extreme. ”
Han Zhaozhi nodded: "It is undeniable that you are." ”
Shen Leng asked, "What about the other one?" Xue Huayi? ”
Han Zhaozhi shook his head: "No, it's Cen Zheng." ”
Shen Leng's face changed: "How is that possible!" ”
Han Zhaozhi said: "Of course it can't be, he and I are both old ministers from the palace, and ...... He's the Snare Box, so isn't he the least likely one? ”
Shen Leng: "Yes." ”
He asked Han Zhaozhi: "But what do you want to express after you say so much?" Expressing me and Cen Zheng is the biggest suspicion? ”
Han Zhaozhi said: "No, what I want to say is that the thinking of the two of us is different, what you think is that you are innocent, Cen Zheng is innocent, all your thoughts are inferences of innocence, and you think that Xue Huayi may be guilty, so your thoughts about him are inferences of guilt." ”
Shen Leng fell silent.
Han Zhaozhi patted him on the shoulder: "Your disadvantage is that you believe in the people you care about, not the people you are familiar with, so that you can analyze them rationally...... You asked me to help you review, let me help you speculate, I said so much to tell you that, in my opinion, everyone is guilty. ”
Shen Leng nodded: "I understand, you can't be swayed by my thoughts, so what you helped me review must not be what I want, and what I want is just proof of my innocence." ”
Han Zhaozhi snorted: "Everyone is like this, innocent people want to prove their innocence." ”
Shen Leng let out a long breath again, and picked up the remaining half pot of wine on the table that Han Zhaozhi had drunk: "When I didn't come." ”
Han Zhaozhi: "I ...... grass"
Shen Leng: "I got a lot of from you for a pot of wine." ”
Han Zhaozhi said: "Half a pot." ”
Shen Leng put down the wine, leaned forward, and asked very seriously: "What was the big case that stumped you and the nine-year-old back then?" ”
Han Zhaozhi was silent.
After a long time, he picked up the flask and took another sip: "About the Queen of Sin...... And yours, nine-year-old wants to prove her innocence. ”
Shen Leng was stunned.
"Actually, if I had reacted that night, there would have been no incident of injuring Mr. Shen at the age of nine, and he talked to me for a long time on the night he left Chang'an City, about the old things in the palace, who was wrong."
Shen Leng asked, "Which one?" ”
"The Queen of Sin, and the Queen ......"
At that time, it was still the queen and the concubine, and further on, the princess and the side concubine.
Han Zhaozhi said: "Before that, Your Majesty asked me and the nine-year-old to secretly investigate the crime queen and the Yang family, at that time the nine-year-old felt very uncomfortable, when he was in the palace, the crime queen was very good to him, and he was an orphan brought into the palace after the crime, people will always be grateful, at that time he felt that it was Concubine Zhen who was wrong, if Concubine Zhen did not enter the palace, there would be no later transformation of the princess." ”
Shen Leng said: "Everyone is guilty. ”
Han Zhaozhi nodded: "Well, it was at that time that no one was innocent when the nine-year-old said it, and everyone was guilty." ”
Han Zhaozhi's mood was obviously low, and he said with some sadness: "I didn't realize how painful the nine-year-old was that night, he should have just received an order from the queen of the crime to let him kill you and Mr. Shen." ”
Shen Leng shook his head: "So the nine-year-old senior, like me, when making judgments, habitually think, people who are close to you will not be wrong, and people who are not close to you must be wrong." ”
Han Zhaozhi said: "So there is a law in this world. ”
Shen Leng fell silent.
Daocheng Mansion.
Xue Huayi took a shower and changed his clothes, his study furnishings were extremely simple, and some of the ornaments in this room were quite valuable, but he asked them to clean them out and return them to the Daozhi Mansion.
He is a clean man, no matter what his purpose is, no matter what his thoughts are, he is indeed such a person, there is not a single flaw in his resume, he is as clean as a lotus flower out of water.
"Your Excellency."
Zhen'er pushed open the door and came in, carrying a bowl of medicine: "The medicine has been boiled." ”
Xue Huayi frowned: "Can you stop eating?" ”
"I can't."
Zhen'er put down the medicine bowl: "I watched you finish drinking." ”
Xue Huayi had a very serious hidden disease, the lake saw the flood, he rushed too far ahead, and in fact, he was also infected with the plague, if it weren't for the medical hall's superb medical skills, he might have died in the place where he fought the disaster.
Soaking in dirty water for a long time made his legs hurt from time to time, and he spent more time in dirty water than anyone who was fighting the disaster, any soldier under him, the soldiers rotated, but he didn't rotate, and the plague hurt his lungs, and he still needed to be regulated, and he didn't know if he could be recuperate.
"Zhen'er."
"What's wrong, sir?"
"You and Zhao'er...... Let's go back to the south in a while. ”
"Why?"
Zhen'er's face changed.
"We're both gone, who's going to take care of the adults?"
"I don't need to be taken care of, I'm fine myself."
Xue Huayi closed his eyes, and all that went back and forth in his mind were the faces of those people, Shen Leng, Han Zhaozhi, and Cen Zheng......
I don't know why, Xue Huayi, who has never been afraid, faintly felt a little afraid, he felt that something might happen to him this time.