Liu Guoxian did not accuse Qin Hui, but Song Gaozong Zhao Gou, and the way of accusation was also unusual - "The minister is guilty, Your Majesty is sacred, you can learn from it, a heart!" (The minister is guilty, but Your Majesty Shengming should see my painstaking heart.) ）&1t;/p>

It's a pity that in just over 100 words, it is impossible for Liu Guo to tell us in detail about "what happened back then", and we can't know why Yue Fei "hates bitterness" like him. &1t;/p>

After that, although I read a lot of historical materials at the turn of the two Song Dynasty, for many years, I still could not fully understand the meaning of Liu Guo's intentions, until one day, I accidentally saw a short historical commentary by Liang Jinzhu of the Qing Dynasty: &1t;/p>

The minister flew to death, the minister Junxi, the minister Jun was speechless and loyal, the four princes of the Chen Hui night newspaper, and the minister was called the minister since then. (Yue Fei died, Zhang Jun was full of joy, Zhang Jun didn't say a word, Han Shizhong was depressed from then on, Qin Hui wrote a letter to secretly report Yue Fei's death to the fourth prince, the supreme military commander of the Jin State, and Zhao Gou could rest assured that he would bow down to the Jin State.) ）&1t;/p>

This historical commentary raises a question that many historians have overlooked, that is, the abnormal performance of the main battle faction after Yue Fei was imprisoned - "Chen Jun is speechless". &1t;/p>

Many historical materials prove that after Yue Fei was imprisoned, the world knew his injustice, that is to say, not only the emperor Zhao Gou and the prime minister Qin Hui, who were the masterminds, understood it, but the civil and military officials in the court, whether it was the main battle faction, the main defense faction, or the main peace faction, or the main surrender faction, actually knew the mystery of this case. &1t;/p>

However, except for Han Shizhong, who had been relieved and idle at that time, he came to the door to question Qin Hui, and the civil and military officials of the imperial court did not say a word, and none of the main battle faction figures wrote to Zhao Gou to defend Yue Fei. &1t;/p>

Yue Fei was imprisoned, and they didn't organize a rescue - this is too unreasonable. &1t;/p>

What is even more unreasonable is that Qin Hui and Wan Qiao, who presided over the trial of Yue Fei's case, could not produce any strong evidence, and finally killed Yue Fei on "trumped-up" charges. &1t;/p>

Yue Fei, a figure with great military achievements and a mighty town in the Central Plains, was put to death on the basis of "trumped-up" charges alone! &1t;/p>

"Who will be the three-character prison and this Great Wall?" &1t;/p>

On the surface, "unwarranted" means that the crimes listed have not been verified or cannot be verified, and the judgment of those in power alone directly convicts people. In essence, it is actually the person in power who imposes certain crimes on others out of some ulterior motive, and uses power and various means to make unjust prisons, so as to achieve the goal of punishing or even killing others. Since these charges are not based on facts at all, but are set up exactly according to the objectives intended by those in power, they certainly do not stand up to verification. &1t;/p>

But another question arises: Zhao Gou and Qin Hui, who deliberately framed Yue Fei, still can't weave Yue Fei's crimes, why did Liu Guo, who was full of reverence for Yue Fei, say "the minister is guilty" in the words? &1t;/p>

This history is full of doubts and fog. &1t;/p>

Historians of all dynasties have questioned this history, Xu Mengxin of the Southern Song Dynasty compiled the "Three Dynasties and Northern Alliances", and Li Xinchuan compiled the "Records of the Years since the Establishment of Yan", and when writing about this history, it was pointed out that when the son of Qin Hui majored in national history, he covered up and tampered with many truths, so many records are not credible. &1t;/p>

Unfortunately, although the two of them knew that the historical data was unreliable, they did not do in-depth and detailed research on them one by one, leaving a series of major doubts. &1t;/p>

There is something untrustworthy about national history, but what about family history? &1t;/p>

There is also something untrustworthy about the family history, and there are obvious places to beautify Yue Fei in the "Eguo Jintuocui Edition" and "Eguo Jinlun Continuation" compiled by Yue Fei's grandson Yue Ke. Yue Ke "denied his relatives and His Holiness" many things that he thought would damage his grandfather's image. And Yue Fei was rehabilitated in the era of the Zhao and Song dynasties, and Yue Ke naturally did not dare and could not write the contradictions and conflicts between Yue Fei and the emperor into the book. Because of this, he consciously or unintentionally portrayed Yue Fei as a foolish and loyal minister. &1t;/p>

In the Ming Dynasty, after the ninety years of dark and brutal rule of the Yuan Dynasty, the Han people hated the traitors who took refuge in the northern ethnic minorities. &1t;/p>

According to the traditional values of the Chinese, a good person must be a perfect person, and a bad person cannot do a good thing. &1t;/p>

The story of Yue Fei and Qin Hui was transformed, and the indiscreet "mother-in-law's tattoo" began to be widely circulated, and "Man Jianghong" began to be sung all over the world without appearing in Yue Ke's "Eguo Jin Tuo Cui Edition". (The question of whether the swan song "Man Jianghong" in the lyrics was indeed written by Yue Fei is one of the 20 most doubtful cases that will be discussed in this article.) ）&1t;/p>

As for Qin Hui, his case can no longer be overturned. During the Jingkang period, he advocated resistance to Jin and opposed the cession of land for peace; At the moment of his death, he wrote a letter to protest to Jin Shuai in order to protect Zhao Song, and because of this, no one was willing to mention the fact that his family was arrested and taken to Jin Ying. &1t;/p>

There was an official who first came to Hangzhou to take office, went to the Yue Wang Temple to worship, he now Yue Fei, Yue Yun, Zhang Xian's statues are clay sculptures, but Qin Hui's kneeling statue is made of iron, and he was furious at the moment: "Mud Fan Yue Wang, iron cast Qin Hui, do you want to make the traitor immortal?" ”&1t;/p>

The person next to him immediately replied: "At the beginning, they were all made of clay, and everyone respected the statue of Yue Wangye like a god, and the statue of Qin Hui was always smashed, and later Qin Hui was changed into a wooden statue, or it was smashed and cut, and it was changed to an iron-clad wooden one, which was still destroyed, and in desperation, it could only be cast with iron." ”&1t;/p>

Genius site address:. Please read the mobile version of the book at the URL: m.